Defining & Measuring Nursing Outcomes
The purpose of outcomes research is to evaluate: the quality of
care for health conditions and diagnoses of enrolled
populations and the performance of health plans in meeting
patient needs while determining accountability. McCormick 29 has defined health outcomes within three domains: 1) effective clinical interventions used to prevent, diagnose,
treat and manage clinical conditions; 2) methods and data to
advance the clinical application of outcomes; and 3)
evaluation of the impact of clinical outcomes on patient
populations. The use of clinical practice guidelines grounded
in research, in addition to the use of appropriate diagnostic
treatment regimens can improve the quality of patient care
without increasing the cost of care30.
Measuring nursing outcomes to determine if nursing care
makes a difference (what the nurse does for the patient, with
predicted health outcomes that result from specified nursing
interventions) requires a new set of clinical skills.
Nurses need to demonstrate the value of nursing care in terms
of improved outcomes linked to nursing activities and
interventions by evaluating the rate of improvement in a
patient's health status (functional status/self-care,
psychological adjustment and involvement with managing their
health) within the health care system. Examples
of nursing sensitive outcome measures as defined by the
ANA31 for acute care settings include: nosocomial
infection rates; patient injury rates from falls; patient
satisfaction with nursing care; pain management; educational
information; nursing job satisfaction; maintenance of skin
integrity; and staff mix (RNs, LPNs, technicians).
These nursing quality indicators are defined in operational
terms to specifically measure nursing actions (Table 1).
| Table 1. ANA Nursing Quality Indicators and Their
Operational Definitions* |
| Nosocomial Infection Rate: The rate per 1000
patient acute care days at which patients develop clinically
active bacteremia (as defined by CDC) in whom there is no
evidence to suggest that infection was present or incubating at admission (using CDC differential criteria). |
| Patient Injury Rate: The rate at which
patients fall and incur physical injury (unrelated to a
surgical or diagnostic procedure) during the course of their
hospital stay per 1000 patient days. |
| Patient Satisfaction with Nursing Care:
Patient opinion of care received from nursing staff during the hospital stay as determined by scaled responses to a
uniform series of questions designed to elicit patient views
regarding key elements of nursing care services. |
| Patient Satisfaction with Pain Management:
Patient opinion of how well nursing staff managed their pain
as determined by scaled responses to a uniform series of
questions designed to elicit patient views regarding specific
aspects of pain management. |
| Patient Satisfaction with Educational
Information: Patient opinion of nursing staff efforts to educate them regarding their condition and care requirements as determined by scaled responses to a uniform series of questions designed to elicit patient views regarding specific aspects of patient education activities. |
| Patient Satisfaction with Care: Patient
opinion of the care received during the hospital stay as
determined by scaled responses to a uniform series of
questions designed to elicit patient views regarding global
aspects of care. |
| Nursing Job Satisfaction: Job satisfaction
expressed by nurses working in hospital settings as
determined by scaled responses to a uniform series of
questions designed to elicit nursing staff attitudes toward
specific aspects of their employment situation. |
| Maintenance of Skin Integrity: Rate per 1000
patient days at which patients develop pressure ulcers (Grade
II or greater) during the course of their hospital stay, but,
72 hours or more following their admission. |
| Mix of RNs, LPNs, Unlicensed Staff Caring for Patients in Acute Care Settings: The ratios (expressed in
FTEs) of registered nurses with direct patient care
responsibilities to LPNs and unlicensed workers. |
| Total Nursing Care Hours Provided per Patient
Day: Total number of hours worked by nursing staff
with direct patient care responsibilities on acute care units
per patient day. |
*American Nurses Association. (1996). Nursing quality indicators: Definitions and implications. Washington,DC: American Nurses Publishing.
Much work needs to be done to adequately address the
contributions of nursing care on the overall status of
patient outcomes. Currently, the science of nursing
outcomes has progressed from structure and process models to
outcomes-based models. Specifically, nursing needs to:
1) establish the difference nurses make in patient care
versus other health professionals, 2) provide data related to
specific interventions such as pain control, patient safety,
or decrease in adverse events (wound care, decubitus ulcers),
and 3) determine nursing's impact on the continuum of
care or management of a defined patient population.
Outcomes based on the results of nursing care will increase
professional accountability, decrease adverse patient events,
provide changes related to nursing interventions and, over
time, revamp the practice of healthcare. The ANA's Code
for Nurses and Interpretative Statements actually benefits
patients and families and is considered the hallmark of
current professional nursing practice. Therefore,
it is important for staff nurses and consumers of health care
to be aware of the trends associated with evidence- based
clinical outcomes and become familiar with requirements
mandated by accreditating agencies.
Previous: Evidence Based Practice and Patient Safety Next: References
|