|
||||
Table of Contents | Abstract & Objectives | page 1 | page 2 | page 3 page 4 |page 5 |page 6 | page 7 |page 8 | page 9 | page 10 page 11 | References | Websites | Test |
||||
Building on Piaget's work, Kohlberg (1977) described three levels in the development of moral judgement: preconventional, conventional and postconventional. Adolescence
marks the movement from the conventional level of moral judgement to postconventional
(Neinstein, 2002). Early adolescents are typically in the conventional level of moral development. At this level, they are motivated by the need to meet expectations of
external factors such as others' opinions and existing law (Feli & Maehr, 2000). These individuals hold simplistic conceptions of what is right. Postconventional orientation embraces more universal and abstract principles of justice, requiring formal operational thought. The focus moves from actions and motivations to please others, to autonomous
moral principles that are based on the individual's own beliefs. The postconventional
level of moral development begins in middle to late adolescence and is not achieved by
all (Feli & Maehr, 2000). Males rely on thinking and deductive reasoning to reach the "autonomous moral self" (Wren, 1997). Kohlberg believes that the six-stage theory (each level subdivided into 2 stages) applies to both boys and girls; however, the theory is based on the study of boys. In contrast, Carol Gilligan (1993) believes that moral development is different for girls and women. Women seem to exemplify the 3rd stage of six when moral development is measured using Kohlberg's scale. Gilligan (1993) describes an interdependent thinking style that incorporates thoughts and feelings to attain the "interdependent moral self". She states that moral development is centered on the understanding of responsibility and relationships rather than rights and rules. She views moral development in girls as a continuous process. (Wren, 1997) compares the open systems model described by Kohlberg and the spiral model of moral development described by Gilligan. Kohlberg's (1977) model illustrates
an impersonal, rule-guided process of decision-making. While Gilligan's (1993) model
illustrates a continuous process influenced by life's experiences. It is important to be
aware that boys and girls may follow a different process in moral development.
Previous: Cognitive Development
© 2002 American Nurses
Association |