|
Table of Contents
NOTES:
The URLs for all links shown in this report are listed in the Resource section.
When printing this module: Figures referred to in this document have been posted on a seperate page for printing.
Print figures 1 and 2 |
Abstract and Objectives
Every school day, parents send their children to school with the hopes that they will be
healthy and safe and will receive an education. A variety of environmental risks may be
posed in some schools that can make them potentially unsafe and unhealthy, and hinder
children's ability to learn. This independent study module (ISM) provides the reader
with a brief overview of some of the key environmental health risks associated with
schools. Information is presented about the environmental exposures, signs and
symptoms of toxicity, and the nurse's role as an agent of change to help encourage and
produce healthy and safe schools. Children's special vulnerabilities are described, as well
as child-specific information regarding the toxicity associated with exposures. Pesticides,
mercury, asbestos, formaldehyde, radon and carbon monoxide poisonings are discussed.
Because indoor air quality can be an important variable affecting the learning process, a
general section on this issue is presented. Suggestions are provided addressing
environmental health and safety problems, including the use of health and safety
committees, as well as advocacy education approaches. A resource section provides a
brief listing of resources; many of them are websites, which, in turn will link the reader to
additional resources. The EPA's website will be found to be particularly helpful,
especially the children's section and the Indoor Air Quality Tools for Schools section, as
well as the healthy schools network website. The purpose of this independent study
module is to introduce the reader to basic concepts and issues associated with
environmental health risks to children in schools. The University of Maryland has
created a new web site, envirn.umaryland.edu , that contains links to all of the websites noted in this ISM.
Objectives
- Describe children's special vulnerabilities.
- Identify three environmental hazards that may
affect children's health in schools.
- Explain the nurse's advocacy role related to
children's environmental health in schools.
- Specify two resources that can provide
information related to children's environmental health.
- Discuss the goals and characteristics of
integrated pest management.
- List three asthma triggers that may be found in
schools.
- Describe two pollutants that contribute to
indoor air pollution, their sources, and associated health effects.
- Name two variables that may determine a
relationship between exposure to a stressor and a health effect.
Introduction
There have been two shifts in our environmental concerns since the early environmental
movement in the 1960's and 1970's. The first has been a shift from a strictly ecological
focus, where concerns centered on man's negative effects on the natural world, to concern
specifically about the risks posed to human health. Even more focused has been our
interest in children's health. The second shift has been to be more attentive to the
environmental risks associated with the "built" environment: our homes, office buildings,
and schools. This shift has helped to raise awareness about indoor air quality; the
existence of and manner by which we control pests (including insects, molds,
fungus/mildew, and rodents); and the health risks associated with the products that we
use to construct buildings and those products that we bring into our homes, schools, and
offices. Increasingly, concerns are being raised about school buildings, the built
environment that one sixth of the U.S. population can be found in, Monday through
Friday, during the school year. Our concerns are further heightened because the majority
of people found in school buildings are children, who may have distinct vulnerabilities to
environmental health risks.
There are some quick fixes that can be accomplished for school-based environmental
health risks but some environmental health problems will have existed for years;
identifying and reducing them may take time. Some risks are quite complex and will
require changes in purchasing practices; rehab and renovation specifications; and
upgrades of ventilation systems. The best way to address any of the problems will be
from an informed position and with the support of others in the education setting. Take
time to read the section on health and safety committees; health and safety committees
can create a win-win platform for creating environmentally healthy schools that will be
safe workplaces and healthy learning places.
Toxicology
Toxicology, a critical science in environmental health, is the study of the negative effect
of a physical stressor (chemical, biological, or radioactive) on a biological system (a cell,
tissue, organ, organ system, or organism). The key variables in determining the
relationship between an exposure to a stressor and a health effect are: 1) the "dose" of the
exposure; 2) the "duration" of the exposure; 3) the "toxicity" or strength of the toxin; and
4) a variety of "host factors" (such as age, sex, health status, other exposures).
Environmental toxins can enter the human body by ingestion, inhalation, and dermal
exposure. People may ingest toxic chemicals in their drinking water, as well as foods
and beverages. Air pollutants can affect many body systems. Some toxic exposures,
such as solvents and some pesticides, can be absorbed through the skin.
In the same way that the desired effects of pharmacological agents are dose-dependent
and depend on host factors, the effects elicited by toxic chemicals in our environment are
dose-dependent and dependent on host factors. This concept is extremely important
when discussing children's special vulnerabilities to environmental exposures because a
number of variables influence the dose of toxic chemicals to which children are exposed.
Children's Special Vulnerabilities
Children are not just little adults. They are different in many ways, particularly with
regard to their exposures and responses to the environment. As nurses, we know that
infants and young children breathe more rapidly than adults. This increase in respiratory
rate may translate into a proportionately greater exposure to air pollutants. While
infants' lungs are developing, they may also be susceptible to environmental toxicants.
Behaviors characteristic of early childhood also affect a child's exposure to toxicants. In
the first years of life, the young child spends hours close to the ground where he or she may be exposed to toxicants in dust, soil and carpets as well as to pesticide vapors in low-lying layers of air. (Visit www.cehn.org/cehn/WhatisPEH. html. )
Infants and young children drink more fluids per body weight than adults, potentially
increasing their dose of contaminants found in their drinking water, milk, and juices
(particularly pesticides). For example, the average infant's daily consumption of six
ounces of formula or breast milk per kilogram of body weight is equivalent to an adult
male drinking 50 eight-ounce glasses of milk a day (Bearer, 1995). Children also eat
more per body weight and they eat different proportions of food. How many adults could
eat the same amount of raisins pound-for-pound as the average two-year-old? Children
consume many more fruits and fruit juices than adults, which may result in larger doses
of exposure to pesticide residues.
Children play on the floor, the grass, and the playground, placing them at increased risk
for exposure to toxic chemicals that may be applied to or settle on the floors or ground,
including lead-based paint dust, cleaning product residues, and horticultural/agricultural
chemicals (fertilizers, herbicides, pesticides). The hand-to-mouth exploration of the
infant and young child that helps them to learn about their world also places them at
higher risk of exposures. This is particularly true in the case of lead-based paint dust
when it is present in houses and schools. Because metabolic systems are still developing
in the fetus and child, their ability to detoxify and excrete toxins differs from that of
adults. This difference is sometimes to the child's advantage, but more frequently they
are not able to excrete toxins as well as adults, and thus are more vulnerable to them.
Children's bodies also function differently than adults. The rate at which children absorb
nutrients from the gastrointestinal tract is likewise different than the rate for adults, a fact
that can impact their exposure to toxicants. For example, children have a greater need for
calcium for bone development than do adults and will absorb more of this element when
it is present in the gastrointestinal tract. When lead has been ingested into the gut,
however, the body will absorb it in place of calcium. Consequently, an adult will absorb
10 percent of ingested lead, while a toddler will absorb 50 percent of ingested lead
(Bearer, 1995). And finally, some of the protective mechanisms that are well developed
in adults, like the blood-brain barrier, are immature in young children, thereby making
them more vulnerable to the effects of some toxic chemicals.
Why Indoor Air Quality Is Important
Most people are aware that outdoor air pollution can pose health risks, but many do not
know that indoor air pollution can also have significant health effects. Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) studies of human exposure to air pollutants indicate that indoor
levels of pollutants may be 2-5 times, and occasionally more than 100 times, higher than
outdoor levels. These levels of indoor air pollutants may be of particular concern because
most people spend about 90 percent of their time indoors. Perhaps the most sensitive of
school building inhabitants are asthmatic children. Based on a 1997 National Health
Interview Survey (CDC, 2001), it was estimated that 25.7 million people had been
diagnosed with asthma by a health professional in their lifetime. That estimate increased
to 26.3 million in 1998. The highest prevalence was seen in children 5-17 years of age,
with 130.1 per 1,000 in 1997 and 135.0 per 1,000 in 1998 (CDC, 2001). Asthma
accounts for an estimated 10.1 million lost school days annually (CDC, 2001).
|
Asthma Triggers Include
|
| Allergic Reactions: | pollens, feathers, molds, animals, some Foods, house dust, latex |
| Infections: |
Influenza, Pneumonia |
Second Hand Smoke
Cockroaches
Emotional Stress & Excitement
Vigorous Exercise
Cold Air |  |
| Occupational Dust & Vapors: | plastics, grains, metals, wood, sulfur dioxide, auto exhaust, grains, ozone |
| Sleep (Nocturnal Asthma) |  |
| Household Products: | paint, cleaners, sprays, drugs, aspirin |
| Heart Medications |  |
| www.lungusa.org/asthma/astastrig.html |
In recent years, comparative risk studies performed by EPA and its advisory board have
consistently ranked indoor air pollution among the top five environmental risks to public
health. Children may be especially susceptible to air pollution. The same concentration
of pollutants can result in higher body burdens in children than adults because children
breathe a greater volume of air relative to their body weight.
Over the past several decades, our exposure to indoor air pollutants has increased due to a
variety of factors, including the construction and renovation of more tightly sealed
buildings, reduced ventilation rates to save energy, the use of synthetic building materials
and furnishings, and the use of personal care products, pesticides, and housekeeping
supplies. In addition, our activities and decisions, such as deferring maintenance to
"save" money, can lead to problems from sources and ventilation. Indoor air pollutants
can originate within the building or be drawn in from outdoors. If pollutant sources are
not controlled, indoor air quality (IAQ) problems can arise, even if the heating ventilation
and air condition (HVAC) system is properly designed, operated, and maintained. Air
contaminants consist of particles, dust, fibers, bioaerosols, and gases or vapors.
Indoor air pollutant concentration levels can vary by time and location within the school
building, or even a single classroom. Pollutants can be emitted from point sources, such
as science storerooms, or from area sources, such as newly painted surfaces. Also,
pollutants can vary with time, such as only when floor stripping is done, or continuously,
such as mold growing in the HVAC system.
|
Unique Characteristics of Schools
|
- Occupants are close together, with the
typical school having approximately four times as many occupants
as office buildings for the same amount of floor space.
- Budgets are tight, with maintenance often
receiving the largest cut during budget reductions.
- There are a variety of pollutant sources,
including art and science supplies, industrial and vocational
arts, home economic classes, and gyms.
- A large number of heating, ventilating,
and air conditioning systems place an added strain on maintenance
staff. As schools add space, the operation and maintenance of each
addition is often different.
- Schools sometimes use rooms, portable classrooms, or buildings, which were not
originally designed to service the unique requirements of schools.
|
Heating, ventilation, and air condition system design and operation can impact the
temperature, humidity, and contaminant level in the building. The heating, ventilation,
and cooling system includes all heating, cooling, and ventilating equipment serving a
school: boilers or furnaces, chillers, cooling towers, air handling units, exhaust fans,
ductwork, and filters. A properly designed and functioning HVAC system:
- Controls temperature and relative humidity to provide thermal comfort
- Distributes adequate amounts of outdoor air to meet ventilation needs of school
occupants
- Isolates and removes odors and other
contaminants through pressure control, filtration, and exhaust fans.
Not all HVAC systems are designed to accomplish all of these functions. Some buildings
rely only on natural ventilation. Others lack mechanical cooling equipment, and many
function with little or no humidity control.
Nurses are often the only health care providers in the school setting. School nurses are
aware of the health status of the students and those with particular vulnerabilities. This
knowledge and awareness places school nurses in a special position to make a link
between health effects experienced by the school population and the environmental
conditions within the school. School nurses have a tremendous opportunity to educate
students, parents, and staff and provide resources regarding IAQ issues. By tracking and
documenting symptoms, and association with particular rooms or areas in the school
building, nurses can provide a crucial role in connecting health complaints to the school
environment.
Indoor Air Quality problems are most likely to affect those with preexisting health conditions and those who are exposed to tobacco smoke. Student health records should include information
about known allergies and other medically documented conditions, such as asthma, as
well as any reported sensitivity to chemicals. Privacy considerations may limit the
student health information that can be disclosed, but to the extent possible, information
about students' potential sensitivity to IAQ problems should be provided to teachers.
This is especially true for classes involving potential irritants (e.g., gaseous or particle
emissions from art, science, or industrial/vocational education sources).
|
Common Sources of Indoor Air Pollutants
|
|
Outside Sources
Polluted Outdoor Air
- pollen, dust, mold spores
- industrial emissions, vehicle emissions
Nearby Sources
- loading docks
- odors from dumpsters
- unsanitary debris or building exhausts
near outdoor air intakes
Under Ground Sources
- radon
- pesticides
- leakage from underground storage
tanks
|
Components and Furnishings
Components
- mold growth on soiled or water-damaged materials
- dry traps that allow the passage of sewer gas
- materials containing volatile organic compounds, inorganic compounds, or damaged asbestos
- materials that produce particles (dust)
Furnishings
- emissions from new furnishings and floorings
- mold growth on or in soiled or
water-damaged furnishings
|
|
Equipment
HVAC Equipment
- mold growth in drip pans, duct-work, coils, and humidifiers
- improper venting of combustion products
- dust or debris in duct-work
Non-HVAC Equipment
- emissions from office equipment (volatile organic compounds, ozone)
- emissions from shops, labs, cleaning
processes
|
Other Indoor Sources
- science laboratories
- vocational arts areas
- copy/print areas
- food prep areas
- smoking lounges
- cleaning materials
- emissions from trash
- pesticides
- odors and volatile organic compounds from paint, caulk, adhesives
- occupants with communicable diseases
- dry-erase markers and similar pens
- insects and other pests
- personal care
products
|
Pesticides
"Pesticides are substances intended to destroy, control or repel pests, such as insects,
weeds, fungi, rodents, and bacteria. Depending upon the dose, pesticides may cause a
range of harm such as cancer, acute or chronic injury to the lungs, nervous, reproductive,
and endocrine and immune system damage and may accumulate in the environment.
Children are at greater risk of pesticide exposure than adults because pound for pound of
body weight, children not only eat more and breathe more, but they also have a more
rapid metabolism than adults and they play on the floor and lawn where pesticides are
commonly applied".
There is a growing body of scientific data about the harmful effects that pesticides have
on children's health, both acute and chronic. Acute affects of exposure include eye and
throat irritation, skin rashes, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, headaches, flu-like symptoms,
upper respiratory distress, and in extreme cases, death. Chronic effects (those that appear
long after exposure) include an increased risk of some types of cancer, reproductive
impairment, and neurological damage (US EPA, 1999). Several studies have examined
the relationship between childhood cancers (brain cancer, Ewing's sarcoma, Wilm's
tumor, acute lymphoblastic leukemia, non-Hodgkin's lymphoma) and pesticide exposures
(McBride, 1998; Daniels, 1997; Buckley, 2000; Meinert, 2000; Infante-Rivard, 1999).
The potential risks illustrated by these studies suggest a need for a precautionary
approach when dealing with pesticide exposures and children.
Dr. Elizabeth Guillette (1998) identified two groups of Mexican children who were
similar in all respects, but one, their exposure to pesticides. High levels of multiple
pesticides were found in the cord blood of newborns that lived in an agricultural valley
area as compared to children who lived in the foothills where pesticide use is avoided.
Children in both groups were asked to draw a picture of a person. Their drawings (in
figures 1 and 2) graphically illustrate the effect pesticides had on study participants' neurological development.
| 5-year-olds with sustained pesticide exposures
Draw a person
Figure 1. | 5-year-olds without sustained pesticide exposures
Draw a person
Figure 2. |
Routes of exposure to pesticides include inhalation, ingestion, and
dermal penetration. Eighty percent of ambient exposures to pesticides
occur indoors; measurable levels of up to a dozen pesticides have been
found in the air inside of homes (US EPA, 1988).
|
NURSING ACTIONS
Obtain Indoor Air Quality: An Introduction for Health Professionals.
- Contact IAQ INFO, (800) 438-4318.
Maintain Student Health Records
- Include information about sensitivities to IAQ problems in student health records.
- Allergies, including reports of chemical sensitivities.
- Asthma.
- Completed health records should exist for each student.
- Health records should be kept
updated.
Track health-related complaints by students and staff.
- Keep a log of health complaints that notes the symptoms, location and time of
symptom onset, and exposure to pollutant sources.
- Watch for trends in health complaints,
especially in timing or location of complaints.
Recognize indicators that health problems may be IAQ-related.
- Complaints are associated with particular times of the day or week.
- Other occupants in the same area experience similar problems.
- The problem abates or ceases, either immediately or gradually, when an occupant
leaves the building and recurs when the occupant returns.
- The school has recently been renovated or refurnished.
- The occupant has recently started working with new or different materials or
equipment.
- New cleaning or pesticide products or practices have been introduced into the
school.
- Smoking is allowed in the school.
- A new warm-blooded animal has been
introduced into the classroom.
Inform students and staff about the importance of good hygiene in preventing the spread of airborne contagious diseases.
- Provide written materials to students (local public health agencies may have
information suitable for older students).
- Provide individual instruction/counseling
where necessary.
Provide information to parents, staff and students about IAQ and health.
- Help teachers develop activities that reduce exposure to indoor air pollutants for
students with IAQ sensitivities, such as those with asthma or allergies (contact the
American Lung Association [ALA], the National Association of School Nurses [NASN],
or the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America [AAFA].
- Collaborate with parent-teacher groups to offer family IAQ education programs.
- Conduct a workshop for teachers on health
issues that covers IAQ.
Establish an information and counseling program regarding smoking.
- Provide free literature on smoking and secondhand smoke.
- Sponsor a quit-smoking program and
similar counseling programs in collaboration with the ALA.
Environmental Protection Agencies' Indoor Air Quality Tools for Schools available on-line at www.epa.gov/iaq/schools/toolkit.html.
|
Integrated Pest Management
"Integrated pest management [IPM] is an increasingly useful approach to minimizing
pesticide use while providing long-term pest control. It integrates both chemical and
non-chemical methods to provide the least toxic alternative for pest control" (American
Academy of Pediatrics, 1999). Traditional pest control has relied heavily on pesticides as
the first plan of attack. IPM differs in that it does not automatically rely on pesticide
application. Schools should adopt an official IPM statement to serve as a guide for the
process of development, implementation, and evaluation of a program. If no IPM
program exists, a committee should be organized to develop a program.
|
NURSING ACTIONS
- Know the signs and symptoms of pesticide poisoning and develop an emergency
response plan for an acute poisoning. Information on the signs and symptoms of
pesticide poisoning can be found in an EPA publication entitled Recognition and
Management of Pesticide Poisonings. (Publication can be doownloaded at http://npic.orst.edu/rmpp.htm)
- Influence pesticide management in schools by
educating staff, parents, and students about the issues of pesticide
exposure, alternatives to pesticide use, and IPM programs.
- Encourage school officials to adopt an official
IPM approach to pest management.
|
| For more information on IPM in schools, the Environmental Protection Agency has the following resources available:
Pest Control in School Environments: Adopting Integrated Pest Management is a
brochure that identifies ways for schools to reduce dependence on pesticides in school
buildings and landscapes and discusses alternative methods for managing pests
commonly found in schools. To order a free copy, call (800) 490-9198.
EPA's web site on IPM in schools that provides
information on EPA's efforts to reduce children's exposure to pesticide use in schools.
A national directory of IPM in schools web sites created to assist individuals with finding specific information about each state IPM program, as well as appropriate IPM state contacts is available at: http://schoolipm.ifas.ufl.edu/ipm_org.htm.
Other EPA publications include:
- Recognition and Management of Pesticide
Poisonings
- Pesticides and Food: What You and Your Family Need to Know
- Ten Tips to Prevent Pesticide and Lead Poisonings
- Citizen's Guide to Pest Control and
Pesticide Safety
To order free copies of the publications listed above, call (800) 490-9198.
|
|
The EPA has banned, or phased out the use of two older pesticides that do not provide an
adequate margin of protection for children.
Chlorpyrifos - On June 8, 2000, the EPA announced an agreement with chemical
manufacturers to phase out the home and garden uses of this insecticide by the end of the
year, but the agreement will allow existing stocks to be depleted. It will continue to be
used on all foods (except tomatoes), golf courses, green houses, mosquitos, and for fire
ant control. New home treatment for termites with chlorpyrifos will continue until
December of 2005.
More information
Diazinon - The EPA has recently banned over-the-counter sales of the insecticide
Diazinon. However, individuals may not be aware of this and may continue to use their
inventories in homes and schools. The EPA has not yet eliminated all uses of Diazinon.
More information
These chemicals should not be placed in the trash. Any inventories should be taken to a
hazardous waste facility for disposal.
|
| General First Aid Guidelines For Pesticide Exposure:
Swallowed poison. Induce vomiting ONLY if emergency personnel on the phone tell you
to do so. It will depend on what the child has swallowed; some petroleum products or
caustic poisons will cause more damage if the child is made to vomit. Always keep Syrup
of Ipecac on hand (1 ounce for each child in the household) to use to induce vomiting if
recommended by emergency personnel. Be sure the date is current.
Poison in eye. Eye membranes absorb pesticides faster than any other external part of the body; eye damage can occur in a few minutes with some types of pesticides. If poison
splashes into an eye, hold the eyelid open and wash quickly and gently with clean
running water from the tap or a gentle stream from a hose for at least 15 minutes. If
possible, have someone else contact a Poison Control Center for you while the victim is
being treated. Do not use eye drops or chemicals or drugs in the wash water.
Poison on skin. If pesticide splashes on the skin, drench area with water and remove
contaminated clothing. Wash skin and hair thoroughly with soap and water. Later, discard
contaminated clothing or thoroughly wash it separately from other laundry.
Inhaled poison. Carry or drag victim to fresh air immediately. If you think you need
protection such as a respirator and one is not available to you, call the fire department and
wait for emergency equipment before entering the area. Loosen victim's tight clothing. If
the victim's skin is cyanotic or the victim has stopped breathing, give artificial respiration
and call rescue service for help. Open doors and windows so no one else will be poisoned
by fumes.
Additional pesticide product information can be obtained from the National Pesticide Telecommunications Network (NPTN) at (800) 858-7378. NPTN is a toll-free
information service operated seven days a week from 6:30 a.m. - 4:30 p.m, PST
(9:30 a.m. - 7:30 p.m. EST) , excluding holidays. E-mail | Web site.
Also at NPTN is the National Antimicrobial Information Network (NAIN) which provides informationabout antimicrobial products - sanitizers, disinfectants, and sterilands. Telephone 1-800-447-6349, 6:30 a.m. - 4:30 p.m, PST excluding holidays. FAX: 1-541-737-0761. E-mail | Web site | Mailing address: NAIN, Oregon State University, 333 Weniger Hall, Corvallis, OR 97331-6502. |
Asbestos
Asbestos is a mineral fiber. It can be positively identified only with a special type of
microscope. There are several types of asbestos fibers. In the past, asbestos was added to
a variety of products to strengthen them and to provide heat insulation and fire resistance.
From studies of people who were exposed to asbestos in factories and shipyards, we
know that breathing high levels of asbestos fibers can lead to an increased risk of lung
cancer; mesothelioma, a cancer of the lining of the chest and the abdominal cavity; and
asbestosis, in which the lungs become scarred with fibrous tissue. The risk of lung cancer
and mesothelioma increases with the number of fibers inhaled. The risk of lung cancer
from inhaling asbestos fibers is also greater for smokers. People who get asbestosis have
usually been exposed to high levels of asbestos for a long time. The symptoms of these
diseases do not usually appear until about 20 to 30 years after the first exposure to
asbestos. Most people exposed to small amounts of asbestos, as we all are in our daily
lives, do not develop these health problems. However, if disturbed, asbestos material may
release asbestos fibers, which can be inhaled into the lungs. The fibers can remain there
for a long time, increasing the risk of disease. Asbestos material that would crumble
easily if handled, or that has been sawed, scraped, or sanded into a powder, is more likely
to create a health hazard (Available on-line at www.epa.gov/iaq/pubs/asbestos.html).
Intact, undisturbed asbestos-containing materials generally do not pose a health risk.
They may become hazardous and pose increased risk when they are damaged, are
disturbed in some manner such as during school renovation and repair, or deteriorate over
time and thus release asbestos fibers into building air. In response to the Asbestos Hazard
Emergency Response Act, EPA published the Asbestos-in-Schools Rule. The rule
requires public and private elementary and secondary schools to inspect for friable (easily
crumbled) and non-friable asbestos, develop management plans to address hazards, and
conduct responses to eliminate the asbestos. The rule also specifies training, examination,
and other requirements to accredit persons who do this work, and sets requirements for
warning signs and transportation and disposal of materials containing asbestos.
Additional information about the federal laws regulating asbestos in schools can be found
on the EPA web site at www.epa.gov/asbestos/pubs/asbestos_in_schools.html.
Formaldehyde
Formaldehyde is one in a large family of chemical compounds called volatile organic
compounds or "VOCs." The term volatile means that the compounds vaporize at normal
room temperatures. Some VOCs can cause watery eyes, burning sensations in the eyes,
nose and throat, nausea, coughing, chest tightness, wheezing, skin rashes, and allergic
reactions. Humidity and temperature will affect the off-gassing (release of gaseous
chemicals from a solid material) of formaldehyde from products such as pressboard.
Pressboard is commonly found in temporary school buildings. Although professional
advice should be solicited to resolve concerns, the school can immediately respond to this
concern by providing ventilation whenever possible.
Radon
The EPA ranks indoor radon among the most serious environmental health problems
facing us today. After smoking, it is the second leading cause of lung cancer in the United
States causing an estimated fourteen thousand (14,000) lung cancer deaths a year. Radon
is a naturally occurring gas that may seep into buildings from the surrounding soil. In
some cases, well water may be a source of radon. You cannot see, taste, or smell radon.
In fact, the only way to discover if high levels of radon are present is by testing.
The National School Radon Survey estimated 19.3 percent of U.S. schools, nearly one in
five, have at least one frequently occupied ground contact room with short-term radon
levels above 4pCi/L - the level at which EPA recommends mitigation (US EPA, 1993).
Radon can enter the school building or any other building when warm air rises, creating a
vacuum in the lower areas of the school. Air seeps in from the soil around and under the
school, and some air is sucked in through openings (cracks, doors, windows) on the lower
levels. Radon gas decays into radioactive particles that can be trapped in the lungs. This
can damage lung tissue and lead to lung cancer. An individual's risk of developing lung
cancer from radon exposure depends on the dose and duration, as well as the presence of
environmental tobacco smoke. The EPA recommends that all schools be tested for radon; as of February 1999 only 20 percent have been tested For additional information on radon, contact the
National Safety Council at (800) SOS-RADON.
Carbon Monoxide
|
School Nurse Identifies Family's Chronic
CO Poisoning
All the members of a family of four living in a Baltimore area townhouse were suffering
from the symptoms of chronic carbon monoxide poisoning. These symptoms included:
cold and allergy symptoms, headaches, dizziness, sinus pain and fatigue. The symptoms
manifested slightly differently in each family member. The eight-year-old daughter was
suffering recurrent headaches, dizziness and subsequent falls in school and became a
frequent visitor to the nurse's office. The nurse became concerned, and after learning of
the symptoms experienced by the rest of the family, instructed them to have the CO
levels in their home checked. A Baltimore Gas & Electric technician verified that the
levels in the home were very elevated.
|
Carbon monoxide is produced by the incomplete combustion of carbon materials; any
flame or combustion device is likely to emit carbon monoxide. Carbon monoxide may be
present in auto shops, home economics or other kitchen rooms, or in rooms that take in
air from areas where buses or other vehicles idle. Carbon monoxide can get trapped
inside an area when: appliances do not work properly; a stove or furnace is not working
properly due to a clogged chimney or vent; a car or bus is left running in an enclosed
space or near an air intake area; or a charcoal grill is used in a closed area (CPSC, 1993).
Carbon monoxide combines with hemoglobin to form carboxyhemoglobin, which is
incapable of carrying oxygen, resulting in tissue anoxia. The health threat from exposure
to CO is especially serious for those with cardiovascular disease. Healthy individuals may
also be affected, but at higher levels of exposure. Early symptoms of exposure include
flu-like symptoms (headache, fatigue, nausea). Principle manifestations of acute carbon
monoxide poisoning are shortness of breath and a bright red color of mucus membranes
(CPSC, 1993).
| CO Precautions:
-
Make sure appliances are installed according to manufacturers' instructions and
local building codes. Professionals should install most appliances. Have the heating
system (including chimneys and vents) inspected and serviced annually.
- Install a CO detector/alarm. The label should reference UL standard 2034 or the
requirements of the IAS 6-96 standard. A carbon monoxide detector/alarm can provide
added protection, but is no substitute for proper use and upkeep of appliances that can
produce CO.
- Be certain that cars and buses do not idle near the air intake vents for the school.
|
Mercury
Mercury is a naturally-occurring element that is present throughout the environment.
"Mercury contamination results from exposure through the air, water, food or soil, or
through direct contact. Exposure to metallic mercury (as opposed to methylmercury that
is ingested) occurs when it is not stored in a closed container. Contamination may include
the spilling of metallic mercury on clothes, furniture, carpets, floors, walls, the natural
environment, and even the human body. Metallic mercury and its vapors are extremely
difficult to remove from items such as clothes, furniture, carpet, floors, and walls. The
vapors will also accumulate in walls and other structures in contaminated rooms. The
contamination can remain for months or years, posing a risk to exposed individuals"
(Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1997).
"In the human body, mercury accumulates in the liver, kidney, brain, and blood. Mercury
may cause acute or chronic health effects. Children exposed to metallic mercury for long periods may have trouble learning in school (Centers for Disease Control, 1997). Mercury is a recognized developmental neurotoxicant linked to mental retardation, gait and visual disturbances, neurological damage, and impairment of language, attention and memory. Repeated exposure to relatively low toxic levels can cause muscle tremor, irritability, personality changes or gingivitis." ( Reeder, R., 1995, p.2) Acute exposure (i.e., short term, high dose) is not common today due to greater precautions and decreased handling. However, acute effects may include severe gastrointestinal damage, cardiovascular collapse, or kidney
failure, all of which could be fatal. Inhalation of 1-3 mg/m3 for 2-5 hours may cause
headaches, salivation, metallic taste in the mouth, chills, cough, fever, tremors,
abdominal cramps, diarrhea, nausea, vomiting, tightness in the chest, difficulty breathing,
fatigue, or lung irritation. Symptoms may be delayed in onset for a number of hours"
(Michigan State University, 1996).
If a mercury spill occurs, there are specific methods that should be used for clean-up.
First, notify the hazardous materials team, which may be part of the local fire department.
A spill will require the evacuation of persons and animals from the contamination site,
the use of special equipment and ventilation, and the need to assess the effects to people
who have come in contact with the contamination site. For an explanation of this process
see the website for Health Care Without Harm.
| NURSING ACTIONS
Nurses can play a critical role in reducing mercury exposure from school settings, and
consequently reducing mercury from our overall environment, including the waste
stream. All mercury containing products in the school should be identified and replaced.
Replace mercury thermometers with mercury-free ones. Make arrangements to safely
dispose of whatever metallic mercury you might have in your school by calling your state
department of the environment and asking for guidance from the hazardous materials
section. Do not throw mercury products in the garbage. Garbage is incinerated or land-filled; both of these processes will release the mercury back to the environment. If no
chemical management plan exists in the school, the nurse should advocate for the
development of a health and safety committee (i.e. administrators, health care providers,
staff, students, and parents) who can be responsible for the development and
implementation of a chemical management plan, as well as an emergency response plan.
Outside consultation should be obtained on areas that are beyond the scope of expertise
represented in the committee.
Accident Spill Response
Detailed instructions of how to clean up mercury spills can be found on the EPA web site at www.epa.gov/epaoswer/hazwaste/mercury/faq/spills.htm
|
| Possible Sources of Mercury in Schools (This list is not inclusive.) |
| Product | Description | What To Do | Mercury-free Alternative |
| Thermometers | Silver liquid in tube | Bring to hazardous waste facility | Alcohol or digital thermometer |
| Thermostats | All non-electrical models | When it needs replacing, call the national thermostat
recycling program |
Electronic "set back" models can help on energy
bills
|
| Fluorescent lights | Light bulbs in the form of long tubes | Continue to use these, but recycle them at the hazardous
waste facility. Do not crush |
None, although some new bulbs have less mercury than
others
|
| Old alkaline batteries | Bought before 1990 | Bring to hazardous waste facility |
Rechargeable batteries
|
| Maze toys | contain a blob of mercury
| Bring to hazardous waste facility |
Mercury-free games
|
| Old toys that light up or make noise | May contain mercury button batteries | Bring to hazardous waste facility |
Toys that don't light up or make noise
|
| Chemicals in school lab | May contain mercury products |
Identify and bring to hazardous waste facility for
disposal
| Mercury free chemicals |
| Manometers on blood pressure cuffs |
Contains mercury
|
Identify and bring to hazardous waste facility for
disposal
|
Replace with non-mercury cuff
|
| Arts and crafts supplies | May contain mercury |
Identify and bring to hazardous waste facility for
disposal
| Mercury free supplies |
| Cleaning products | May contain mercury |
Identify and bring to hazardous waste facility for
disposal
| Purchase non-toxic or less toxic cleaning products |
| Motion switches | May be found in cars in the auto shop |
Use care not to break the switches if removing; bring to a
hazardous waste facility
|
Use non-mercury switches if
available
|
Environmentally Preferable Products
The selection of building products, cleaning products, art and science supplies, and many
other products that are used in schools can influence the health risks in the school. The
use of less toxic products in schools is recommended by many as a zero to low-cost way
to help protect indoor air quality in schools. In addition to creating indoor air quality
pollution, hazardous chemicals often create pollution during their manufacture and
disposal. Some pollute water and air; others must be disposed of as hazardous waste, or
cause more harm when their containers are buried in landfills or burned in incinerators
(Healthy Schools Network ).
Rubber cement, permanent felt tip markers, pottery glazes, enamels, spray fixatives, and
other potentially hazardous materials are sold for use in schools, despite the fact that there
are often animal and human studies demonstrating their toxicity. Chemicals used in arts
and crafts supplies, and biological and chemical agents used for laboratory sciences, such
as formaldehyde, may be toxic. Paints, glues, and other art, science, and vocational
supplies contain chemicals that can be toxic to children and pollute the air. Industrial arts
courses can expose children to metal dusts, fumes, and wood dust. Chemicals such as
acetic acid, aminophenol, ammonia, hydrochloric acid, etc., are found in photo labs that
often lack safety equipment and proper ventilation. Kiln firing can release clay dust,
which can contain silica (known to cause fibrosis) and toxic gases such as carbon
monoxide and heavy metals from the glazes. Home economics and theater exposures
may include fabric dyes, oven cleaners, cosmetics, hairsprays, and fog and smoke effects
generated from machines using glycols and mineral oil. Copy machines produce ozone
that has been linked to lung problems and should be run only in well-ventilated rooms.
Of the 80,000 chemicals in commercial use today, only a very small fraction have been
individually tested for toxicity. Unless a chemical is a food, drug, or cosmetic, there are
virtually no requirements for complete toxicity testing (animal or human). The 1996 Food
Quality Protection Act now requires more extensive testing of pesticides than previously
required. Tests on various chemicals acting in combination with one another are
practically non-existent. Despite this, a wide variety of toxic or hazardous products are
routinely used in buildings. Schools are no different, except the majority of school
occupants are children packed very close together. Nurses or facility managers should
obtain Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS) for any chemicals used in building. These
can be obtained from the chemical manufacturer.
Management
Involvement in product selection for use in our schools is of critical importance. Environmentally preferable purchasing (EPP) is an effective management tool defined by the Executive Order 13101 [PDF] as "products or services that have a lesser or reduced
effect on human health and the environment when compared with competing products
or services that serve the same purpose...". Some common examples of EPP include purchasing paper products
and cleansers that do not contain chlorine, and non-toxic all purpose cleaners and art
supplies. Nurses should advocate for the development of EPP standards to be included in
school purchasing policies.
| Indoor Air Quality Management Plan
The Environmental Protection Agency has developed a guidance tool that is designed to
allow you to prevent and solve the majority of indoor air problems. It is called Indoor
Air Quality: Tools for Schools. This IAQ Management Plan involves implementing the
following steps on a periodic basis, at least once each year. The IAQ coordinator and
team can perform the steps as presented, or the steps can be tailored to the specific needs
of your school. The steps are grouped into three categories: Assess Current Status,
Perform Repairs and Upgrades, and Final Steps. A thorough description of this tool can
be found online.
- Initiate a checklist log
- Activate the IAQ team (Can be the same as the health and
safety committee.)
- Receive and summarize the IAQ checklists
- Perform a walkthrough inspection
- Assess radon status
- Assess pest control program
- Assess lead status
- Identify recent changes that affect IAQ
- Set repair and upgrade priorities
- Gain consensus and approvals
- Distribute status report
- Perform repairs and
upgrades
|
Health and Safety Committees
Nurses who work in school settings and nurses who are parents to children in school
settings can play a significant role in affecting the environmental quality of schools.
Because there is no single person who can "make" a school environmentally healthy and
safe, a good place to start is with a committee of people who may each play a role in
improving the school's environment. In many workplaces, health and safety committees
provide the structure through which to address conditions that may pose risks to health.
Because schools are both workplaces for adults and learning places for children, creating
a health and safety committee can provide a forum in which a multidisciplinary team can
learn about health and safety issues; develop and exercise assessment capabilities;
prioritize concerns and issues; develop an intervention plan; and provide a feedback loop
regarding the success of the remediation and other intervention activities. A health and
safety committee can also propose policies. Some of the people who could be considered
for a school health and safety committee would be teachers, principals, parents, custodial
staff, facilities managers, a school board representative, and even a student.
The Environmental Protection Agency has created an action kit entitled Indoor Air
Quality Tools for Schools that provides a complete program that schools can implement
to assess and address indoor air quality concerns. To obtain a kit at no cost, call the EPA
clearing house at (800) 438-4318.
| Some of the issues that should be addressed when considering the development of a health and safety committee in a school include:
- Who will chair the meetings? Will the group elect a chair? Will it be a member of
the school's management? Should it be shared by a parent, employee, and principal (or
other manager)? Should facilitation of the meetings be rotated? Who will take notes and
how will they be distributed?
- How often will the committee meet, for how long, and where? Will you include
facilities "walk-through" as part of your meeting? Every meeting?
- Once a problem is identified and an intervention suggested, who is responsible for
its implementation? What is the recourse of the committee if the intervention is not
implemented?
- What is the appropriate mechanism
for communicating to the whole school and parent community
when a problem has been identified or any other finding or
decisions of the committee, including recommendations for
actions?
|
| A Healthy and Safe Nurse's Office
What a nurse can do in his or her immediate domain:
- Eliminate the mercury thermometers and mercury blood pressure cuffs. Replace
them with non-mercury ones. (Make sure that the mercury containing ones are disposed
of properly because they are considered hazardous waste.) See www.noharm.org
- Eliminate latex-containing products, particularly latex gloves. Many children and
adults are allergic to latex. See ANA's latex web site.
- Request that the health suite NOT be routinely sprayed with pesticides, especially
if your school has a regularly scheduled pesticide application. Employ IPM techniques if
pests are noted. See: www.childproofing.org/poisonedschoolsmain.html
- Check the ventilation in the health suite. Are the vents free from obstruction? Do
you know where the "fresh air" intake is located? Check to make sure that the intake is in
a location that is as healthy as possible. See:
www.epa.gov/iaq/schools/tfs/guide5.html.
- If there are any signs of moisture problems, request that maintenance repair the
problem.
- Check to see if there is lead-based paint in your suite.
- Since sick students and staff frequent the health office, it is important to take steps
that can help prevent transmission of airborne diseases.
- Ensure that the ventilation system is properly operating.
- See that air filters are clean and properly installed.
- Question whether air removed from the health suite circulates through the
ventilation system into other occupied areas. If so, request that this situation be
addressed.
- Obtain Material Safety Data
Sheets (MSDS) for any chemicals used in building from
the chemical manufacturer.
|
Conclusion
Nurses are becoming increasingly involved in environmental health issues. In this
article, some of the key environmental health risks found inside schools have been
presented, including pesticides, mercury, asthma triggers, formaldehyde, and carbon
monoxide. Children's special vulnerabilities to environmental exposures were explored,
especially as they pertain to the school-aged children. Nursing actions to reduce
environmental exposures in schools were outlined, including directions for creating an
environmentally-healthy nursing suite. Additionally, guidance was provided regarding
collective action and advocacy through the creation of and participation in environmental
health and safety committees.
Nurses are vital members of the community in identifying and addressing
environmental health issues and must begin to prepare themselves better for this role.
There are several great resources that can assist you in your quest for an environmentally
healthy school. The ANA's health and safety staff are a wealth of information. The
Office of Children's Health Protection and the Indoor Environments Division at the EPA
are extremely helpful, as are the national non-profit organizations: The Children's
Environmental Health Network, the Healthy Schools Network, The Children Health and
Environment Coalition, and The Center for Health and Environmental Justice (See the
resource section for web site addresses). And finally, the University of
Maryland has created a unique web site for nurses on environmental health.
Nurses in the community (school nurses, public and community health nurses, and nurse-parents) can all play a significant role in the environmental health status of our schools.
Nurses are trusted members of the community, seen as having the best interest of the
community in mind. This trust can help nurses be educators and agents of change on
environmental issues.
Resources
EnviRN.umaryland.edu: a one-stop shop created by the University of Maryland School of Nursing for nurses interested in environmental health.
American Nurses Association: see RN noharm/Pollution page for more on environmental health issues.
United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
Children's Environmental Health Network: www.CEHN.org
Healthy Schools Network: www.healthyschools.org
Center for Health, Environment and Justice: www.chej.org
National Center for Environmental Health (NCEH), Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC) NCEH Provides expertise in environmental pesticide surveillance and
disease outbreak investigations. Visit www.cdc.gov/nceh/ default.htm
Consumer Product Safety Council: www.cpsc.gov
Agency for Toxic Substance Disease Registry (ATSDR): For fact sheets and information on pesticides: www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxfaq.html
ATSDR Information Center toll-free at 1-888-422-8737 or e-mail ATSDRIC@cdc.gov
Preventing Harm:
This is a resource and action center on children and the environment. Visit www.preventingharm.org
Health Care Without Harm: www.noharm.org
The American Lung Association: www.lungusa.org, (800) LUNG-USA
References
American Academy of Pediatrics, Committee on Environmental Health. (1999). Handbook of Pediatric Environmental Health. Elk Grove Village, IL: American Academy of Pediatrics
Bearer, C. (1995). Environmental Health Hazards: How Children Are Different From Adults. Future of Children Summer/Fall 1995;5(2):11-26.
Buckley, J., Meadows, A., Kadin, M., Le Beau, M., Siegel, S., & Robison, L. (2000). Pesticide exposures in children with non-Hodgkins lymphoma. Cancer 89(11), 2315-12
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). (1997, May). ATSDR and EPA warn the public about continuing patterns of metallic mercury exposure.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC): Epidemiology & Statistics Unit. (Jan, 2001). Trends in Asthma Morbidity and Mortality.
Daniels, J., Olshan, A., & Savitz, D. (1997). Pesticides and childhood cancers. Environmental Health Perspectives, 105(10), 1068-77.
GAO Report to the Ranking Minority Member, Committee on Government Affairs, U.S. Senate. Pesticides: Use, effects, and alternatives to pesticides in schools, November, 1999. Washington, DC: GAO/RCED-00-17.
Guillette, E., Meza, M., Aquilar, M., Soto, A., & Garcia, I. (1998). An anthropological approach to the evaluation of preschool children exposed to pesticides in Mexico. Environmental Health Perspectives, 106(6), 347-353.
Infante-Rivard, C, Labuda, D., Krajinovic, M. & Sinnett, D. (1999). Risk of childhood leukemia associated with exposure to pesticides and gene polymorphisms. Epidemiology, 10(5), 481-7.
McBride, M. (1998). Childhood cancer and environmental contaminants. Canadian Journal of Public Health, 89(1), 53-62.
Meinert, R., Schuz, J. Kalersch, U., Kaatsch, P., & Michaelis, J. (2000). Leukemia and non-Hodgkins lymphoma in childhood and exposure to pesticides: results of a register-based case-control study in Germany. American Journal of Epidemiology, 151(7), 639-46.
Michigan State University, Office of Radiation, Chemical and Biological Safety. (1996).
Moglia, D., Smith, A., MacIntosh, D. , & Somers, J. (2006). Prevalence and Implementation of IAQ Programs in U.S. Schools. Environmental Health Perspectives, 114 (1).
Reeder, Rachel (1995). The case against mercury: Rx for pollution prevention. Washington, DC., Terrene Institute.
Reigart, J. & Roberts, J. (1999). Recognition and Management of Pesticide Poisonings. (US EPA Publication No. 735-R-98-003). Washington, DC: United States Environmental Protection Agency Office of Prevention, Pesticides, and Toxic Substances.
United States Consumer Product Commission. (1993). Protect your family and yourself from CO poisoning. (US Consumer PSC No 0-356-764). Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
United States Environmental Protection Agency. (September, 1988). The Inside Story: A Guide to Indoor Air Quality. Washington, DC: Office of Air and Radiation, EPA.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA). (July 1993). Radon Measurement in Schools. (EPA 402-R-92-014). Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (September 27, 1999). Chlorpyrifos incident review update, memo by Jerome Blondell, health statistician, Health Effects Division.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency: Region 8. Pesticides, Toxic Chemicals & Children.
|